Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Tribeca kills for 'Dream Home'


By Sarah Sluis

Though I'm not a big horror fan, I've had some luck with Asian horror films, which tend to be more inventive both stylistically and in terms of plot. Such was the case with Tribeca Film Festival selection Dream Home, a Chinese horror film with a protagonist whose killings are motivated by the Hong Kong housing crisis.



DREAMHOME_3 I was expecting the movie to respond, in some way, to America's own housing crisis, but that's like fitting a square peg into a round hole. Josie Ho plays a woman who desperately wants to buy her own flat. In the Hong Kong housing market apartments go for $3,000 a square foot (with 30% down!), making even tiny apartments worth millions of dollars. She resorts to killing the tenants of an apartment in an effort to make it vacant. As expected, the plot is inventive, moving back and forth between her one-night killing spree and various points in her life before that, from her childhood to just a few weeks before. However, it was hard for me to see how someone could resort to killing just for an apartment. In America, there was the opposite problem, with tons of housing stock encouraging unqualified buyers to get in too deep. What the two places have in common is the desperation with which people pursue the dream of having a place of one's own, even when it goes against all logical reasoning.

In the Q&A afterward, one horror fan commended director Pang Ho-Cheung for his original death scenes. Ho-Cheung said he came up with the killing ideas by "going around my apartment and looking at how things could be used differently." Indeed, the deaths are very original, both in the type of implements used to cause them and the pacing of the deaths. People wriggle around in their death throes for ages, pinned down or trapped or strangled but still holding on for life (this is the kind of thing that makes horror fans laugh and everyone else squirm and cover their eyes). Vacuum storage bags, coffee tables, and bed slats are all used as weapons, and, believe me, the deaths are not immediate. Ho-Cheung's horror film is also light on suspense. He uses it sparingly, usually in the approach before the attack. Without suspense, the audience is more relaxed. Those that like watching people killed (and that includes the director: "We just started killing

DREAMHOME_2
and it was so happy we just kept on doing") got their fair share of original death scenes.

Ho-Cheung also revealed that the role was originally written for a man, but actress Josie Ho expressed interest in a role where she could kill people and took on the part. He maintains that they changed nothing in the script to adapt it to her, a statement that rings mostly true (the dynamic with her married boyfriend seems like it must have been changed a bit). In the killing scenes, this works quite well. Her creative methods of killing seem better motivated, and when she is occasionally being outmatched in strength and being choked, it's very believable. At the same time, her character is an incredibly strong and determined personality, with no discernable weakness.

A final thought: the movie hinges on the weeks before October 31, 2007, the moment when Hong Kong's stock market was at its ultimate high before coming crashing down. Hong Kong audiences know this date, so it's helpful to place the moment in your mind as equivalent to right before all the banks and housing markets crashed in the U.S. As for the movie itself? Horror fans will come away more than fulfilled, but those like me, who only like the genre at its best-of-the-best moments (Audition, Uzumaki, Old Boy), won't have a new favorite to add to their list.



Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Catching the Tribeca spirit with 'Soul Kitchen'


By Sarah Sluis

Yesterday I caught my first Tribeca Film Festival screening...ever. Despite my fears of hectic, standing-room-only crowds, I found the Village East Cinema frantic in a good way. Yes, there were people waiting

SoulKitchen outside in the rain hiding beneath their umbrellas to get rush tickets before the show. But just as many people were crowded within the halls of the theatres, waiting for their shows, talking, writing, and making the place look like a temporary home.

Seeing a film with a festival audience is an experience well worth the crowds. It's always fun to hear people laugh unexpectedly, or the person next to me whispering in recognition when someone on screen spoke a line of Chinese (I think the Chinese words might have revealed that one of the characters was cheating on the other). A passionate, engaged audience can make a good film great.

I've been on a Hollywood-heavy diet lately, so it was refreshing to take in an independent, foreign-language film. FJI's executive editor Kevin Lally recommended Soul Kitchen (and wrote about it here), a German movie with an independent spirit. You could count all the ways it's not a typical Hollywood movie, which brings me to just that: all the ways it's different than say, restaurant rom-com No Reservations.

Parts of the movie seem like they're going to be predictable, but end up being played out in a much different way than you expect. When the manager of a Hamburg restaurant with terrible food teams up with a rock star chef, you assume they're going to turn the restaurant into a hot spot with rave reviews. Instead, the regulars hate the food, and it's only when a band starts practicing there and one of the fans requests something from the chalkboard menu that hasn't been taken down yet that the restaurant bit starts taking off. The whole movie just isn't that goal-oriented. The changes the restaurant undergoes are only part of the story, and the manager doesn't even want to turn his place into a super-trendy or four-star restaurant. That's surprising to audience members like me, who are so used to scripts revolving around accomplishments and failures.

Thanks to the inclusion of that great Hollywood trope, the eye lock between people who later fall in love, most of the romantic permutations can be guessed, but how they actually unfold is different than a typical romance. It's also fantastic to see a film cast with people that have a non-Hollywood look to them. Yes, some of the stars are beautiful, but all in unconventional ways. You get the feeling that if these people were actors in Hollywood, they would have much different haircuts/noses/figures/teeth.

Soul Kitchen, which has received a great deal of kudos over the festival, is perfectly suited to its environment, and will be at home when it opens this August through independent-minded IFC Films.



Monday, April 26, 2010

Memories of 'Memento' at Tribeca


By Kevin Lally

In 2000, audiences at the Venice and Toronto Film Festivals were among the first to see Memento, the Memento ingenious second feature by a young British writer-director named Christopher Nolan. What a differencea decademakes. Today, Nolan is one of the most successful filmmakers in the world, having directed thethird-highest grossing film of all time, The Dark Knight (behind James Cameron's Avatar and Titanic).



To commemorate the tenth anniversary of Memento, the Tribeca Film Festival on Saturday screened a handsome print of this riveting modern film noir, followed by a panel discussion moderated by NPR's Robert Krulwich with Jonathan Nolan, Christopher's brother and author of the short story on which the film is based, stars Guy Pearce and Joe Pantoliano, New School psychology professor William Hirst, and MIT professor of behavioral neuroscience Dr. Suzanne Corkin. The event was sponsored by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, which partners with Tribeca each year in awarding grants to narrative film projects that dramatize science and tecnology themes.



The Sloan Foundation connection in this case was the panel's consensus that Memento is one of the movies' most accurate depictions of how the brain and our memories function. For those unfamilar with the film, Pearce plays Leonard, a man who suffered brain trauma while fighting his wife's attacker and who is now unable to retain new memories. Despite his disorienting handicap, he is determined to find the man who murdered his wife. In a daring stylistic choice that mirrors Leonard's own chronic confusion, the sequence of events ispresented backwards in time, forcing the audience to piece together thefracturednarrative.



Jonathan Nolan confessed that when his brother proposed the backwards structure for his screenplay adaptation, he thought it was "a really bad idea," but later came to realize that the fun of the movie is discovering the story "in the moment" along with the main protagonist.



Pearce said that when he read the complexscript, he responded most strongly to the emotional plight of his character. During production, he didn't really worry much about navigating all the story's twists and turns, since from scene to scene, "I didn't need to remember."



Pantoliano, known to one and all as "Joey Pants," with credits ranging from the pimp in Risky Business to a lowlife in "The Sopranos," brought his typically brash perspective to the discussion of memory: "I say I nailed my wife on the first date; she says it was six months later."



Dr. Corkin noted that Memento isn't precisely about short-term memory loss per se, sincewe retain ourshort-term memoriesfor less than 30 seconds unless we rehearse or encode them. Dr. Corkin could draw from personal experiece in watching the film; for more than 40 years, she consulted with a patient who couldn't generate any new memories after brain surgery for a severe epileptic condition. In all their meetings over all those decades, he never recognized her.



For all those who feel their memories of Memento are clear, Jonathan Nolan revealed that the DVD deliberately contains slight differences from the original theatrical release. So seeing this widescreen modern masterpiece back on the big screen was truly a special event for the Tribeca crowd.



'Dragon' rises above 'The Back-up Plan' and 'Losers'


By Sarah Sluis

In an impressive fifth-week feat, How to Train Your Dragon ascended to number one over the weekend with a $15 million gross and a $10,000 per-screen average. There's two lines of reasoning to explain the rise. One is word-of-mouth. Anyone who's seen the movie (judging from my own reaction and Facebook status updates) has been blown away by the impressive visuals, cute characters and great story. Second is the overcrowded slate during Dragon's release. The movie released as 3D Alice in Wonderland was winding down, and a week later 3D Clash of the Titans opened, crowding the 3D market. Because this movie is so The back-up plan jennifer lopezquality, I'm glad to see audiences rewarding the film by voting for it with ticket sales.

The Back-Up Plan was at first place on Friday before settling in at second place with $12.2 million. The romantic comedy finished roughly in line with expectations. This kind of lackluster performance is the reason people think women don't go to movies--when really, they're saving their movie dates for Sex and the City and Twilight.

The Losers had a disappointing #4 debut. The movie was expected to open above $10 million but came away just shy with $9.6 million. Given its

The losers walking in movie withering reviews, this movie got what was coming to it.

Oceans, the Earth Day release from Disneynature, brought in $6 million over the weekend for a four-day cumulative gross of $8.4 million. The nature film opened below last year's Earth, which earned over $8 million its opening weekend and $14 million from Wednesday to Sunday. However, this type of film tends to play well over several

Oceans movie weeks. Last year's Earth may have benefited from a Wednesday Earth Day, which gave the movie more time to build through the weekend.

Last week's limited releases Exit Through the Gift Shop and The Secret in their Eyes held extremely well. Exit Through the Gift Shop dropped 12% while adding three locations. Each of the eleven locations earned $13,500, the highest per-screen average of the week, for a total of $149,000. The Secret in their Eyes went up 120% from last week going from 10 to 33 locations. Its per-screen average of $11,000 was the second-highest of the week.

This Friday, the environmental comedy Furry Vengeance will open wide opposite the remake of A Nightmare on Elm Street.



Friday, April 23, 2010

Aim low this weekend with 'The Back-Up Plan' and 'The Losers'


By Sarah Sluis

Audiences looking for entertainment this weekend will be hard-pressed to find a new offering with rave reviews. Leading the pack is CBS Films' The Back-Up Plan (3,280 theatres), a tired romantic comedy

The back up plan conga line about a woman (Jennifer Lopez) who falls for the perfect guy just as she becomes pregnant with a child conceived with a sperm donor. When I reviewed the movie, I concluded that there's "nothing to see for anyone who's already viewed their fair share of formulaic romantic comedies." Still, for those that enjoy that kind of film, the experience will be "a not very good and yet painless waste of time," as A.O. Scott of the The New York Times so aptly put. The movie is expected to open in the teen millions. A debut on the low end of expectations could put it behind How to Train Your Dragon, which should also post a teen-million figure.

An action-adventure film with an intriguing cast and not much else, The Losers (2,396 theatres), also comes with a caveat emptor. FJI critic Ethan Alter cautions that "the real losers are those folks tricked into forking

The losers giant gun over good money to see this dumbed-down adaptation of the popular comic book." The adaptation follows a group of CIA special operatives who are ordered killed by someone in their own agency. They escape death and turn to wreaking vengeance on the hit man. The cast includes action alums such as Zoe Saldana (Avatar) Chris Evans (Star Trek) and Jeffrey Dean Morgan (Watchmen). Unfortunately, they seem stuck in a movie that seems disorganized and extensively re-worked. This movie is expected to barely cross over into the ten-million range.

After opening yesterday, Earth Day, Oceans will go into the weekend on 1,206 screens, a high number for a nature documentary. The film has already earned $54 million overseas, boding well for its U.S. release. Last

Oceans movie year's Disneynature Earth Day release, Earth, earned $8.8 million its opening weekend on a similar number of screens, so Oceans will probably open in line with those numbers.

The specialty releases this week are a mixed bag. Daniel Eagan despised the "sloppy, thoughtless" documentary Behind the Burly Q (NY), which tries to glorify burlesque while glossing over the drug and sexual abuse that goes along with the profession. Those in the mood to see people with questionable morals would be better served by viewing the "gaggle of (take your pick) hugely rich, greedy, sneaky, promiscuous, self-serving, coke-indulging, desperate denizens of the contemporary art world" in Boogie Woogie (NY).



Tribeca Film Festival enters year nine


By Kevin Lally

The ninth annual Tribeca Film Festival (TFF) kickedoff Wednesdaynight with the world premiere of DreamWorks Animation's Shrek Forever After, one of 85 features to be presented over the course of the 12-day event.



Launched in 2002 with the aim of revitalizing downtownManhattan after the Sept. 11 tragedy, TFF has grown quickly into a signature New York event, a more wide-ranging alternative to the highly selective New York Film Festival held at Lincoln Center each fall.



The selections span the globe and every imaginable genre, from disturbingdocumentaries to light comedies, from poignant dramas to pulpy horror films. Among the hottest ticketsare Freakonomics, the movie adaptation of the best-seller which brought a social dimension to economics, with contributions from some of today's top documentary makers including Alex Gibney (Taxi to the Dark Side), Morgan Spurlock (Super Size Me) and Eugene Jarecki (Why We Fight), and Saturday Night, actor James Franco's inside look at the making of a "Saturday Night Live" episode, which will be followed by a panel discussion with Franco and "SNL" cast members. Alex Gibney returns with an untitled new documentary about disgraced New York governor Eliot Spitzer, and rap icon turned movie auteur Ice Cube delivers Straight Outta L.A., a documentary about the Oakland Raiders and the early West Coast rap scene.



So far, I've caughtthirteenof the Tribeca selections, and for me the clear highlight is Soul Kitchen, the Soul Kitchen new film from Turkish-German director Fatih Akin, whose The Edge of Heaven was one of my favorite movies of 2007. Soul Kitchen is much lighter in tone than that fatalistic drama, even if its young Greek protagonist suffers from an awful run of bad luck. Zinos Kazantsakis (played by Akin's co-writer Adam Bousdoukos) runs an unpretentious restaurant in Hamburg and makes plans to leave the country when his girlfriend lands a job in China. But complications ensue, from his thieving brother on parole, to a onetime friend who's scheming to take over his property, to a slipped disc that seems to get progressively worse as his problems mount. Akin's latest features a zany cast of characters, great music, delectable-looking food, and a breakneck pace as Zinos' fortunes rise and fall and rise again. IFC Films opens it in August, and audiences will leave Soul Kitchen will a satsified smile.



IFC also has Cairo Time, a lovely showcase for leading actress Patricia Clarkson and the sights and sounds of Egypt. Clarkson plays Juliette, who arrives alone for a vacation in Cairo after her husband, a U.N. worker, is delayed by a crisis in Gaza. Her husband's Egyptian former business associate Tareq (Aleander Siddig of Syriana) picks her up at the airport and becomes her host and confidant. As Juliette opens herself to the beauty and contemplative rhythms of the Egyptian culture, it becomes clear that the two are falling in love. Will they act on their attraction? Ruba Nadda's understated romance casts a spell, and will certainly find an enthusiastic audience among women "of a certain age."



On the wilder side, Tribeca is presenting Arias with a Twist: The Docufantasy, a look at the collaboration of veteran New York drag performer Joey Arias and master puppeteer Basil Twist. This double portrait makes the casefor both men as special and unique artists, and I for one now regret having missed their 2008 stage show. The movie opens with Arias, hair in a tight bun and wearing a severe, skimpy Thierry Mugler costume, performing Led Zepellin's "Kashmir" while strapped to a gyroscope, as Twist's space aliens surround him. From the glimpses seen here, the uninhibited Arias and the visionary Twist are an ideal theatrical match.Bobby Sheehan'smovie doesn't have an unkind word to say about either artist and borders on gushiness, but Arias and Twist come across as genuinely likeable anddown-to-earth creative whirlwinds. As abonus, thedocumentary also offers a breezy history of the downtown New York performance-art scene that Arias helped nurture.



Another wild fellow was Ian Dury, lead singer of the British punk band The Blockheads, who gets a colorful tribute in the British biopic sex & drugs & rock & roll. Dury, who died in 2000, was a singular groundbreaker, a music star who never let the crippling effects of his childhood polio stand in his way. Mat Whitcross' film has trouble finding the narrative momentum in Dury's life, and depends too much on the thread of the musician's bad influence on his young son (played by Bill Milner of Son of Rambow), but it's a sensational showcase for Andy Serkis (so memorable as the CGI Gollum in the Lord of the Rings films), who creates an uncanny impersonation of the raspy, volatile singer and even performs his own vocals with the real Blockheads.



Sony Pictures Classics has two excellent films in the Tribeca lineup: Nicole Holofcener's Manhattan ensemble comedy Please Give, opening April 30 and already reviewed on the Film Journal website, and Micmacs, the highly imaginative new film from Amelie director Jean-Pierre Jeunet, who will be profiled in the June issue of FJI.



Tomorrow I'll be at the tenth anniversary screening of Christopher Nolan's twisty Memento, which will be followed by a panel discussion with stars Guy Pearce and Joe Pantoliano and co-writer Jonathan Nolan. It will be a busy weekend in downtown Manhattan. Look for more Tribeca coverage here next week.



Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Documentaries can now show animal cruelty--and that's a good thing


By Sarah Sluis

Documentaries have to be one of my favorite genres. I love feeling like I've learned something new, and seeing something that "really" happened makes the subject that much more engaging. Because their movies US Vs Stevens animal cruelty are based on facts and events, it can be easy to forget the type of challenges documentary filmmakers are up against.

Like what happens when filmmakers show unsavory sights. On April 20th, the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 in United States vs. Stevens that documentary filmmakers are allowed to show animal cruelty in films, overruling a 1999 law barring its depiction. Surprise! This is actually a good thing. This is a classic case of a law passed for a specific purpose that was applied by prosecutors in an overextended manner, leading the statute to be struck down.

The 1999 law was targeted to prevent a gross genre of sexual fetish videos involving women stepping on small animals. It had a clause allowing depictions of animal cruelty for "serious religious, political, scientific, educational, journalistic, historical, or artistic value." So movies like The Cove and Food, Inc., which show animal slaughter, were in the clear. But a prosecutor can charge someone based on their own definition of "serious," so anyone on the cusp of violating such a law would end up in court as the case was decided. Most media are against such laws for that reason--it can dampen freedom of speech. Though the defendant in the case, Robert J. Stevens, made a questionable film called Pick-A-Winna: A Pit Bull Documentary, which some said was a guise to show off fighting, the case definitely has some gray areas. Stevens claims to be a pit bull lover and owner, and says the documentary was created because of his fascination with pit bulls. He also was sentenced to more time than that football player who had a dog fighting ring. Interestingly, the decision made numerous comparisons to hunting videos, which are popular niche videos that show killing of animals. Even if they're made in states where hunting is legal, if shown in an area where hunting is illegal, they would violate the animal cruelty statute. That kind of inconsistency was a major reason the law was struck down.

So it's good day for documentary filmmakers. Now it's back to getting their subjects to open up to them and be honest.