Harvey Weinstein was back in the media and the MPAA’s bad graces this morning after appearing on "CBS This Morning" to announce the launch of yet another attack on the ratings system. This time, the MPAA managed to incite the very, very public irritation of Weinstein by giving one of his awards-season contenders, Philomena, an audience-restricting R instead of a PG-13 rating. Like that time they tried to give Blue Valentine an NC-17 instead of an R rating (Harvey won that one), or that time they gave The King’s Speech an R instead of a PG-13 rating (Harvey did not win that one), the MPAA has apparently once again acted in a manner that could hurt the success, of the fiscal or Academy Awards variety, of a Weinstein film. A thing not to be borne.
But this particular campaign has gotten off to a remarkably likable start. The hullabaloo managed to transcend a typical Weinstein publicity blitz the moment Judi Dench, in character as James Bond’s late boss M, swiveled to face the camera in a 20-second video spot and pronounced herself resurrected. “Just when you thought I was dead,” M (or PhiloMena) wink-winks, before telling the audience she has an important mission for them. “Are you familiar with M-P-A-A?” she asks at video’s end. Presumably, when the next spot airs tomorrow, we’re to be charged with virtually accosting the MPAA as Weinstein brow-beating stand-ins until the bad guys relent and stop picking on poor old PhiloMena. It’s silly, but also fun, as Weinstein himself acknowledges (“I’m having fun with them”). One would think after 20-odd years – Weinstein launched his first attack on the MPAA back in 1994 when they tried to give Clerks an NC-17 rating (Harvey won that one) – the organization would be a little tired of the Weinsteins’ kind of fun. But the rest of us can enjoy the video clips.
A special M.essage:
Weinstein on "CBS This Morning:"
I do think Weinstein has a point. The difference between one F-word and two F-words in a film that doesn’t otherwise feature unduly adult or mature material seems negligible. I’m less sure how all those Southern church-going families will react to the negative portrayal of the movie’s nuns, but perhaps Philomena’s embodiment of Christian ideals will salve the wound. The ratings appeal is scheduled for next Wednesday, but count on at least another video or two before then.
Thursday, November 7, 2013
'Just when you thought I was dead...'
Thursday, December 9, 2010
'Blue Valentine' successfully fights NC-17 rating
By Sarah Sluis
A month ago, I lamented that Blue Valentine received an NC-17 rating. The portrait of a dying relationship has the emotional impact of a freight train. The sex scenes that supposedly warranted the NC-17 rating are not unusually explicit, just unusually real. It seems artifice and exaggeration provide enough emotional distance to ensure an R rating, while something so shockingly real is so powerful, it feels more naked than the actors themselves.
After hiring some dynamo lawyers, The Weinstein Co. successfully reversed the ratings of Blue Valentine (now an R) and The King's Speech (now a PG-13 despite a profusion of F-words). The King's Speech is actually already in release, and doing quite well, but the lower rating could help as the movie expands its release beyond the arty crowds presumably turning out for the film now.
All the hullaballoo and press (overwhelmingly in defense of the film) over the rating of Blue Valentine seems like a good way to get attention, but a press release sent out by the Weinstein Co. tries to pretend the opposite. Blue Valentine producer Jamie Patricof said, "While this has been a frustrating distraction from the film, the outpouring of support from the industry, journalists and film fans has been truly moving. We are ecstatic, that the MPAA was able to see the honesty that Derek [Cianfrance] was able to achieve in this film and overturned the original rating, so the film can now be seen all across the world." (my emphasis)
Blue Valentine and The King's Speech already hold spots in my top ten for 2010. After all the layoffs and talk of bankruptcy, The Weinstein Co. has made an impressive rally with two stunningly good films. Harvey Weinstein is known for being a master at receiving Oscar nominations, even without a truly stellar film, but this year I can really get behind these movies. I only hope that Blue Valentine will receive as much of a push as the more awards-friendly King's Speech.
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Florida considers ill-advised 'family-friendly' movie tax credit
By Sarah Sluis
The state of Florida is considering expanding a "family-friendly" tax credit bonus to 5% from 2%, adding special language excluding films that promote "nontraditional family values" that has inflamed gay rights groups. Whether or not the bill passes (and it shouldn't, but it's supposed to) I doubt it will be effective in legislating morality. The language in the bill seems closer to the Hays Code (circa the 1930s), which forbade such things as miscegenation, swear words now in PG-rated movies, heavy kissing and depictions of crimes that could serve as "how-tos." The code was also supposed to make sure movies upheld the sanctity of marriage and the home, but all it really did was push certain movie scenes behind closed doors.
Since the 2% credit was established in 2007, only eight films have applied for it, with six receiving the credit. One of the rejects? Confessions of a Shopaholic, rated PG by the MPAA for "mild language and thematic elements," ostensibly because of a scene involving shoppers fighting over a pair of shoes. The movies that have been approved include such family-friendly gems as Old Dogs and a Beethoven sequel. These movies don't seem specifically designed to uphold family values, they only seem as though they somehow managed to avoid offending...and I kind of think that old Republican dudes are just the kind of audience that would approve of a movie called Old Dogs, especially after reading the review. Just as the Hays Code made movies dance around the subjects of adultery, cut to fluttering curtains during sex scenes and throw their gangsters in jail at the end after a film-long spree of violence, this bill will do nothing but reward a random smattering of films--an extra 2% isn't going to make a box-office hit.
Finally, studios hate it when governments try to control what kinds of films they make, and for that reason alone they might choose not to take advantage of the tax credit. Plus, because the credit has such ambiguous language, it would be too risky to base a production there solely because of the credit. The MPAA was originally created to appease the government and replace individual states' censorship boards. And since the 1952 Miracle case, movies have had First Amendment protection (they didn't from 1915-1952), so there's nothing Florida can do when The Kids Are All Right, the Sundance film about a lesbian couple and their children, starts playing at a theatre near them. I wish Florida lawmakers the best with their ineffective legislation, which will do little to encourage filmmaking but much to alienate citizens and the Hollywood community.